Ameriprise Is Paying Retention Bonuses. Just Don’t Call It a “Program”
    Ameriprise
    11/18/20264 min read

    Ameriprise Is Paying Retention Bonuses. Just Don’t Call It a “Program”

    Nothing to see here. Ameriprise Financial doesn't have a retention program, Chairman and CEO James Cracchiolo told Wall Street analysts. "I would just say there's no program," Cracchiolo said during the firm's October 29 earnings call, dismissing reports about retention packages as noise from "recruiters with their own agendas."

    TGG

    The Gershman Group

    Industry Insights

    Nothing to see here. Ameriprise Financial doesn't have a retention program, Chairman and CEO James Cracchiolo told Wall Street analysts. "I would just say there's no program," Cracchiolo said during the firm's October 29 earnings call, dismissing reports about retention packages as noise from "recruiters with their own agendas."

    So what should we call the offers worth up to 100% of trailing-12-month revenue that we've seen Ameriprise make to advisors considering leaving?

    Cracchiolo acknowledged that the firm evaluates individual arrangements, including for advisors who have received offers from competitors. But a broad retention program? He insists there isn't one.

    The distinction seems largely semantic.

    In September, Citywire reported that Ameriprise was offering retention bonuses and discounts on advisory platform fees. I personally know more than a dozen teams that had received offers over a period of roughly 30 to 60 days even though there are NDA’s.

    These are not simply minor accommodations to help advisors with their businesses. They are substantial financial incentives designed to persuade successful teams not to leave. Whether Ameriprise calls that a formal program or a series of individual arrangements doesn't change the economics.

    Ameriprise Has Painted Itself Into a Corner

    We raised concerns about Ameriprise's retention strategy in October after BofA Securities downgraded the stock to Underperform from Buy.

    BofA cited the loss of large advisory teams, increasing competition from independent RIAs and the prospect that retention spending could erode profit margins.

    The bank's analysts identified at least five teams managing a combined $12.75 billion that had left Ameriprise between May and September.

    Ameriprise is now facing a difficult dilemma. If the firm publicly acknowledges a broad retention program, hundreds and maybe now reasonably ask why they aren't receiving similar offers.

    But if it continues selectively paying large teams to stay, it risks creating two classes of advisors: those who threaten to leave and receive substantial financial incentives, and those whose loyalty is rewarded with business as usual.

    The firm can keep writing checks to defend its largest relationships. It can accept the departure of teams unwilling to stay without additional compensation. Or it can address the underlying competitive pressures that prompted those advisors to consider leaving.

    Capital With Strings

    According to the company's latest regulatory filing, outstanding loans to advisors increased 29% to approximately $2 billion as of September 30, up $447 million from a year earlier.

    Those balances include recruiting and practice-related financing, not solely retention payments. But the terms underscore an important issue.

    These contracts have heavy strings attached to them making it economically difficult. Those who take these deals should read the fine print and realize the firm’s today may look very different in the future. Signing to a firm that might be struggling in the future could create long-term consequences for short-term.

    For advisors, that can mean accepting capital today while limiting their ability to consider alternatives tomorrow.

    And the financial obstacles don't necessarily end there. Ameriprise has also pursued legal claims against departing advisors, including teams that moved to LPL Financial. Advisors must also consider the potential complications of transferring clients invested in proprietary products or managed account arrangements.

    These are legitimate considerations before accepting any retention or succession offer.

    Retention Is Not the Same as Loyalty

    For many advisors, the platform continues to work well. But financial incentives don't solve the underlying issue. There is a mass of advisors who are leaving or exploring opposition for a reason. These are the top concerns that we hear from advisors:

    1. GAF and other miscellaneous fees that impact profitability of advisors practices
    2. Overreaching compliance and company policies that some say address “the lowest common denominator”
    3. Inflexible, centralized technology from CRMs to financial planning software to reporting engines.

    The competitive landscape is fierce. Advisors can not only be free of the auspices of the interests of large corporations but also have more options for operating, growing and ultimately selling their businesses. Independent and supported-independent platforms are competing on technology, flexibility, costs and enterprise value, not simply recruiting bonuses.

    Ameriprise can continue spending money to persuade advisors to stay. But that doesn't answer whether its business model offers the same long-term opportunities available elsewhere.

    A retention check can buy another five or ten years of an advisor's career. It cannot guarantee that the advisor still believes the firm is the best home for the business. And calling those checks something other than a retention program doesn't change that.

    Share this article

    Ready to explore your options?

    Connect with our team for a confidential consultation about your career path.